DNA Analyses Prove the Relics of Saint Birgitta are Fake

Saint Birgitta (Saint Bridget of Sweden) was the most celebrated saint of Sweden and one of the six patron saints of Europe. She had eight children, six of whom survived infancy. One daughter was Saint Katarina (or Catherine). Saint Birgitta was known for her works of charity and founded the Bridgettines nuns and monks after the death of her husband.

Putative skulls of Birgitta and Katarina

After Saint Birgitta’s death (Rome, 1373), her remains were boiled to remove soft tissue and the bones were placed in a relic casket. Over time, parts of her remains were gifted to churches, monasteries and prominent people. When her daughter Katarina died, her remains were initially buried, before they were recovered and added to the relic casket, along with the remains of other individuals. Today the casket contains several human remains, including two skulls. Although archaeological and historical data indicated that the skulls belong to Birgitta and Katarina, genetic analysis was required to confirm the authenticity of the remains.

Genetic analyses of the skulls

The two skulls in the relic casket were presumed to belong to Birgitta and her daughter Katarina. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is passed down from mother to child along the direct maternal lineage, so it would be assumed that the skulls would have matching mtDNA profiles. There are three regions of the mtDNA that can be analyzed – HVR1, HVR2 and the coding region.

The geneticists involved in this study sequenced both hypervariable regions and two selections from the coding region. This identified eight differences between the two skulls, confirming that there is no maternal relationship between the two skulls and it is not possible that they belong to a mother-daughter pair.

Radiocarbon dating

Variations in the level and quality of mtDNA between the two skulls indicated that the skulls are of a different age. This was confirmed by radiocarbon dating, which revealed that one skull was from 1215-1270 AD and the second skull from 1470-1670. Neither time period coincides with the time when Birgitta and Katarina lived.

Conclusions

Although archaeological and historical evidence indicates that the two skulls in this relic casket belong to Birgitta and Katarina, genetic evidence confirms that is not the case. The mtDNA profiles obtained from each skull have too many variations for the skulls to belong to a mother-daughter pair. Furthermore, radiocarbon dating confirmed that neither skull is even from the same time period as the deaths of Birgitta or Katarina. Instead this famous casket holds the skulls of two unknown females, and the remains of Birgitta and Katarina may be lost forever.

DNA Database Comparisons

The DNA tests conducted in this study have defined the mtDNA profile of two females who are speculated to have been important Roman Catholics. If you have taken the mtDNA HVR1 and HVR2 (Advanced Maternal Ancestry) test, you can compare your mtDNA against these profiles to see if you may have descended from one of the same maternal lineages.

Hunting for DNA stories at natural history museums

Researchers use a new method to extract DNA from preserved samples, opening the door to exploring the DNA of millions of preserved specimens housed at museums. A slice of history Washington, London, Chicago, Vienna, and Beijing...

Y marks the spot: a genetic explanation to why you have more brothers than...

Have you ever wondered why some families have more boys than girls or why more boys (or girls) are born in certain years? Recently we came across this study that reveals a genetic link...

The Habsburg Jaw and the Genetics Behind Inbreeding

New study links the famous “Habsburg Jaw” to inbreeding, further confirming the idea that inter-family marriages weaken bloodlines by decreasing genetic diversity. Who were the Habsburgs? The Habsburgs dynasty also known as the House of...

Latest Posts

Alzheimer’s disease risk can be moderated, a new study finds

Researchers identify 21 modifiable risk factors for reducing the risk of developing Alzheimer’s disease. The APOE gene is one of the most-significant genetic risk...

Save $30 on the COVID-19 susceptibility DNA test from Genovate

New COVID-19 cases continue to emerge worldwide, making it clear that this pandemic is far from over. Genovate is here to give you easy...

Study finds a link between the severity of COVID-19 infections and blood type

Researchers link genetic changes in the region of DNA that define blood type with susceptibility to COVID-19 infections. Blood type O offers a protective...

ACE2: Genetic clues to COVID-19 infections and treatment

Scientists identify a possible link between genetic variations in the ACE-2 receptor used by coronaviruses to enter cells and susceptibility to COVID-19 infections. Could...

Would a DNA vaccine be able to stand ground against COVID-19?

With so many countries under lockdown, researchers from around the world are racing against time to develop a vaccine for COVID-19. Keeping with our...